Rickhouse
Posts
Buy two. Bunker one. Thank me later.

Buy two. Bunker one. Thank me later.

Danny Bauer
May 10, 2026

Hey Barrelhead 🥃

You don't usually expect a $80 bottle to make you stop mid-sip and recalibrate. But that's the trick Penelope just pulled with Cigar Sessions Chapter 1 — a three-way blend so unconventional it shouldn't work on paper.

The cigar pairing angle is the marketing hook. What's actually happening inside the bottle is something different. And it's the kind of pour that quietly outclasses bottles twice its price.

PROOF OF GENIUS

What year did the TTB officially recognize American Light Whiskey as its own legal whiskey category?

THE WEEKLY POUR

🤝 Sazerac Joins The Bidding Days after Brown-Forman confirmed merger talks with Pernod Ricard, Sazerac jumped in with its own offer. Buffalo Trace + Jack Daniel's under one roof? Whisky Advocate
📊 22 Years In Rickhouse Y Heaven Hill's 2026 Heritage Collection is the oldest the series has ever dropped — 270 barrels distilled in 2003, bottled at 129.2 proof. MSRP $319.99. VinePair
📉 The Barrel Tax Finally Cracks Kentucky's barrel tax — the only one in the world — kicked off its 20-year phaseout this year. Distillers see a 4% break in 2026. Kentucky Law Journal
🏌 Elijah Craig PGA Drop Heaven Hill pulled small-batch barrels from the N and S rickhouses and bottled at 108 proof for the 108th PGA Championship. $36.99 MSRP, shipping now. PR Newswire
🎙 Brown-Forman Merger Breakdown Bourbon Pursuit's roundtable dug into what Brown-Forman's potential merger means for Old Forester, Woodford, and the craft squeeze nobody's talking about. Listen

TOP SHELF

🥃 PENELOPE CIGAR SESSIONS CHAPTER 1

Maybe the Best $80 Bottle You'll Drink This Year

Penelope didn't just blend a cigar pour. They wrote a thesis on what American whiskey can become when you stop coloring inside the lines.

This isn't another "Chapter" gimmick from a brand chasing a marketing calendar. Cigar Sessions Chapter 1 is the kind of bottle that earns the shelf space — and then makes you wonder why some of your $200 bottles aren't doing more.

🥃 Bourbon Flex Score™: 41/50 – A blender's flex that punches way above its price tag.

Category	Score	Justification
Flavor Firepower	9/10	Three whiskey styles in one glass and zero chaos. Chocolate, peach, tobacco — the layering is genuinely impressive at this price.
Story Value	8/10	A blend of bourbon, American single malt, and light whiskey co-developed with two cigar master blenders. Conversation starter built in.
Hunt Factor	6/10	7,500 cases out the door. Limited but findable if you move fast. Allocations vary wildly by state.
Pour Prestige	7/10	Penelope's reputation has caught up to the hype. Bourbon heads recognize the brand. The Cigar Sessions name commands respect.
Repeat Pourability	8/10	Zero burn at 101 proof. Drinks like a daily but with enough complexity to feel special.

Rickhouse Recommendo: Bunker Worthy – At under $80 MSRP, this is one of the best values in the limited release game right now. Grab two — one to drink, one to trade.

Quick Stats

MSRP: $79.99
Secondary: $120–$150 and climbing
Hunting Difficulty: 🥃🥃🥃 (3/5)
Allocation Status: Limited — 7,500 cases (45,000 bottles) one-time release
Best Trade Value: Solid 1-for-1 with most cigar-finished pours, including Blood Oath drops

🔥 Vibe Check

Smells like someone melted a dark chocolate truffle into a vanilla milkshake and dusted it with cigar ash — in the best way. Let it breathe and the candied apple shows up uninvited. The kind of nose that makes your tasting group lean in.

👅 The Sip

Opens with milk chocolate and warm caramel. Then the dried peach kicks in. Then — out of nowhere — a ribbon of tobacco runs through the middle like the blender knew exactly what they were doing. Because they did. The single malt adds a body the bourbon alone can't pull off. Light whiskey carries the ride at the back. Zero ethanol burn at 101.

🎉 Afterparty

Silky toffee. Dark fruit. A clean light oak landing that lingers without overstaying. Drinks more mature than its 6-year age statement suggests.

🏆 Where This Belongs

Pull this when the patio is right and the cigar is lit. Or when you want to hand a friend something they'll text you about three days later asking what bottle that was.

📦 The Hunt

MSRP $79.99 if your liquor store hasn't seen the trade reports. Many already have — expect $90–$110 sticker in cigar shops. Secondary's already drifting to $120+. With only 7,500 cases nationwide, the second-tier markets dry up first. Check Texas, Florida, and the Carolinas before they clear.

→ Trade or Bunker Tip: Buy two if your store has them. One to crack, one to sit on through summer. Cigar-blend whiskey peaks in trade value around Father's Day — and this one is a slam-dunk gift bottle for the cigar guy in any group chat.

🧠 Rick's Final Thought

If most "limited collabs" are a marketing brief in a bottle, Cigar Sessions Chapter 1 is what happens when the blender actually shows up to work.

POUR DECISIONS

LAST CALL

🧠 LAST WEEK'S TRIVIA ANSWER

Last week we asked how many unique barrels Buffalo Trace produced for the original Single Oak Project — the experiment that just became a permanent line with Single Oak Rye Bourbon.

192 barrels
195 barrels
207 barrels
250 barrels

The answer is 192 barrels.

Buffalo Trace hand-selected 96 American oak trees from the Missouri Ozarks, then split each into top and bottom halves — yielding 192 unique tree sections, each turned into its own barrel. The 96 throws people off because that's the tree count.

Across those 192 barrels, Buffalo Trace tested seven variables: mashbill, entry proof, char level, stave seasoning, grain size, tree cut, and warehouse type. That's 1,396 possible flavor combinations. Consumers voted Barrel #80 the winner in 2011, and that exact blueprint is now the inaugural Single Oak Rye Bourbon — $75 for a 375ml. Patience pays.