• Rickhouse
  • Posts
  • 80-proof bourbon is a scam. Here's the proof.

80-proof bourbon is a scam. Here's the proof.

Hey Barrelhead 🥃

You know that feeling when you're staring at two bottles from the same distillery?

One's 80 proof for $40. The other's 120 proof for $80.

Your brain starts doing math. Is the high-proof worth double? Are you just paying extra for alcohol burn? Maybe the 80-proof is the "smart" buy?

I used to think the same thing. Grabbed the lower proof, saved the cash, felt clever.

Then I learned what proof actually does to flavor, secondary value, and your street cred in bourbon circles.

Now I never touch anything under 100 proof. And neither should you.

Here's the proof breakdown that changed everything...

PROOF OF GENIUS

Which Buffalo Trace Antique Collection bourbon earned full “hazmat” status by tipping the scales at a scorching 144.8 proof in its 2007 release—the highest-proof bottling ever to leave the distillery?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

THE WEEKLY POUR

A MESSAGE FROM RICKHOUSE

Win a WhistlePig 15 Year Rye

  • Must be 21.

  • Share rickhouse.news with a friend (who signs up) using the referral link below — it tracks everything automatically 👇

  • More shares + sign-ups = more chances to win.

  • Raffle ends July 31st.

  • Want better odds? Travel back in time and wear a suit to a baseball game.

TOP SHELF

Why That 120-Proof Bottle Is About to Change Your Life (And Your Wallet)

You're standing in the store. Two bottles, same distillery, same age. One's 80 proof for $40. The other's 120 proof for $80.

Your buddy texts: "Grab the barrel proof, trust me."

Here's why he's right, and why proof isn't just a number on a label.

The Proof Truth Nobody Tells You

Proof = ABV × 2

That's it. That's the math your high school teacher said you'd never use.

But … Higher proof doesn't just mean more alcohol. It means more everything.

More flavor bombs. More complexity. More bang for your bourbon buck.

The Gunpowder Test That Started It All

Back in the 1700s, British tax collectors had a problem. Liquor merchants were watering down their hooch to dodge taxes.

The solution? Soak gunpowder in the spirit and light it.

If it exploded. 100 proof.

If it fizzled. You got scammed.

That's right. The proof system literally started because people were trying to rip off the government. Some things never change.

Why Your 80-Proof Bottle Tastes Like Water

Most 80-proof bourbon is watered down to hit a price point.

Distilleries take that beautiful cask-strength liquid (usually 110-130 proof) and add water until it's "smooth enough" for casual drinkers.

What you're really buying: Expensive water with bourbon flavoring.

What you should be buying: The real deal at barrel strength.

The Proof Sweet Spot That Changed Everything

90-100 Proof: The goldilocks zone. Hot enough to carry flavor, cool enough to sip neat.

100-110 Proof: Where the magic happens. Every flavor note gets amplified without torching your palate.

110+ Proof: Welcome to the big leagues. This is where legends are made and taters get humbled.

How Proof Murders Your Wallet (In a Good Way)

The Secondary Market Secret: Higher proof = higher resale value.

Check the group chats. That 80-proof bottle you bought? It's sitting at retail price six months later.

But that 120-proof barrel pick? That's trade bait, baby.

The Water Drop That Broke the Internet

Pro Move: Add 3-5 drops of water to high-proof bourbon.

Why it works: Water breaks down alcohol molecules, releasing trapped flavor compounds.

The result: You just turned your $80 bottle into a $200 experience.

Warning: Don't tell the bourbon snobs. They think adding water is blasphemy.

Proof and Your Cocktail Game

Old Fashioned: 100+ proof or go home. Anything less gets murdered by the sugar and bitters.

Manhattan: 90-100 proof plays nice with vermouth.

Neat pour: Whatever proof makes you feel like a whiskey god.

The Allocation Game Nobody Talks About

Reality Check: Most allocated bottles are high proof.

Why? Because distilleries know that's where the real bourbon heads spend their money.

The Strategy: Build relationships with high-proof releases. They're your ticket to the good stuff.

Rick's Proof Cheat Sheet

80-90 Proof: Training wheels bourbon. Great for beginners, boring for veterans.

90-100 Proof: Daily drinker territory. Enough heat to keep it interesting.

100-110 Proof: The flex zone. This is where you separate yourself from the crowd.

110+ Proof: Big boy bourbon. Earns respect in any bourbon circle.

The Proof Move That Wins Every Time

Next time you're at the store:

  1. Skip the 80-proof shelf fillers.

  2. Find the highest proof from a distillery you trust.

  3. Buy two bottles — one to drink, one to trade.

  4. Watch your bourbon cred skyrocket.

The Bottom Line

Proof isn't just about alcohol content. It's about intensity, complexity, and respect.

Higher proof bottles:

  • Deliver more flavor per dollar.

  • Hold their value better.

  • Give you credibility in bourbon circles.

  • Actually taste like bourbon, not bourbon-flavored water.

Your move: Next time someone offers you 80-proof bourbon, ask them if they have anything with some actual firepower.

Rick's Final Thought: If your bourbon doesn't make you pause and think "damn, that's got some muscle," you're drinking expensive water.

Now go find some proof that matters. 🥃

POUR DECISIONS

LAST CALL

Last week’s trivia: “In the John Wick franchise, which Kentucky bourbon does our favorite Baba Yaga keep on deck?”

Answer: Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon.

Why it’s more than a prop:

  • Cinematic shorthand for “only the best.” The faceted bottle and race-horse stopper cue up Wick’s lethal refinement; the camera lingers on it when he and Winston trade glasses inside the Continental.

  • Hype → hard to find. After those cameos, Blanton’s allocations vanish quicker than a gold coin at hotel check-in—secondary prices regularly double retail.

  • Born to stand out. Launched in 1984 as the first modern single-barrel bourbon, every bottle is labeled by hand and corked with one of eight tiny jockey stoppers that spell B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S—collect them all and you’ve earned your Continental cred.

Keep an eye on your local shelf; blink and the Blanton’s is gone—just like Mr. Wick. —The Ricks

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS WEEK'S BOOZELETTER?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.